Takes responsibility for helping the class come
alive: by offering examples and applications of the ideas studied and by
making connections between material learned in this course and materials
learned elsewhere
Takes risks: by asking for more explanation
and/or examples illustrating a particular point; by being honest about
beliefs and doubts -- even if that means disagreeing with myself or
students; by stating reasons for an unpopular position even when you
personally disagree with it; by suggesting alternate outcomes and
interesting possibilities, even if they might not prove as plausible under
closer scrutiny
Asks questions or makes comments on the assigned
readings which show a real attempt to understand the readings on your own
Really listens to what others say as opposed
to simply talking to impress people, without caring about the issues other
students raise
Takes responsibility for helping others in the
class learn and be part of the discussion: by being patient and not
interrupting others while they're talking or trying to express their views;
by explaining ideas that another student or myself had a hard time
understanding/explaining; by asking other students questions about
statements they made -- either to offer suggestions on how to improve their
ideas, or possible criticisms of which they must take account
The following criteria for classroom
participation is quoted from Professor Margery Enix, Chapman University
whom I thank for showing me how to respectfully dissent.