A: An "A" paper commands attention because of
its insightful development and mature style. It presents a cogent
discussion of its subject and employs well-chosen examples and persuasive
reasoning. It shows that the writer can choose words aptly, use
sophisticated sentences effectively, and observe the conventions of
written English.
B: A "B" paper is clearly competent. It presents
a thoughtful discussion of its subject, and it uses appropriate examples
and sensible reasoning. A "B" paper typically has a less
fluent and complex style than an "A" paper but does show that
the writer can usually choose words accurately, vary sentences
effectively, and observe the conventions of written English.
C: A "C" paper is satisfactory, sometimes
marginally so. It presents an adequate discussion of its subject and
elaborates with sufficient examples and acceptable reasoning. Just as
these examples and this reasoning will ordinarily be less developed than
those in "B" papers, so will the "C" paper's style be
less effective. Nevertheless, a "C" paper shows that its writer
can usually choose words of sufficient precision, control sentences of
reasonable variety, and observe the conventions of written English.
D: A "D" paper is unsatisfactory in one or more
of the following ways. It may discuss its subject illogically; it
may lack coherent structure or elaboration with examples; it may reflect
an incomplete understanding of the subject. Its prose is usually
characterized by at least one of the following: frequently imprecise word
choice; little sentence variety; occasional major errors in grammar and
usage, or frequent minor errors.
F: The qualitative "F" paper shows serious
weaknesses, ordinarily of several kinds. It frequently presents a
simplistic, inappropriate, or incoherent discussion of the topic, one that
may suggest some significant misunderstanding of its subject. Its prose is
usually characterized by at least one of the following: simplistic or
inaccurate word choice, monotonous or fragmented sentence structure; many
repeated errors in grammar and usage. The quantitative "F"
fails to arrive.