Learning Module 4: Activity One
Civil Rights v. Black Power
General
Information: This
activity provides two points of view about the Black Freedom Movement of the
1960s: The Civil Rights Movement and the Black Power, Black Nationalism
movement. The objective of those
associated with the Civil Rights Movement was to end segregation and
discrimination of blacks and to gain full equality. To achieve this objective,
the participants applied a strategy of non-violent direct action. The objective
of those associated with Black Power/Black Nationalism was to empower the black
community so that blacks would unite and take control of their communities and
gain self-reliance, race pride and political and economic empowerment. To
achieve this objective, the participants stated that they would take control by
“any means necessary” and liberate themselves from white domination. In this
activity, we will evaluate and compare the effectiveness of (1) non-violent
direct action and (2) empowerment of the black community.
Timing: November 30
Assessment:
20 points.
Process:
The
Documents: Attached and Posted on the Class Website.
The
Civil Rights Movement:
Black Power, Black Nationalism
Questions
of the Documents: The answers to these
questions will be the basis for the quiz. These questions are at the end of
each document.
Introduction:
The Civil Rights Movement[1]
In 1955 a bus boycott in
which
used marches, boycotts, and similar mass actions to create crises intended to
force segregated southern communities to abandon their Jim Crow laws and
practices. It called for nonviolence on the part of participants, in spite of
racial taunts, arrest, or physical attack. The most visible and eloquent
spokesman for· this approach was a black Baptist preacher named Martin Luther
King Jr. (1929-1968), who had studied the ideas and technique of India's
Mohandas Gandhi and sought to apply a similar method in the struggle for black
equality. As the leader of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC),
he set out to employ his nonviolent strategy in community after community
throughout the South. King became an internationally known figure and in 1964
won the Nobel Peace Prize for his civil rights activities. Although
assassinated in 1968, he remains the most potent symbol of the Civil Rights
movement.
As King and SCLC
brought their strategy to communities throughout the South, new groups adopted
the technique. In February 1960 four black college students sat down· at a
"whites only" lunch counter in Greensboro, North Carolina, and refused
to leave unless they were served. Within weeks, the sit-in movement had spread
to seventy southern cities and attracted thousands of black college students.
Many of them came together in April to form the Student Nonviolent Coordinating
Committee (SNCC). Their tactics were soon expanded to include kneel· ins at
segregated churches and wade·ins at segregated public pools. In 1961 the
Congress of Racial Equality (CORE) sent an interracial group of “freedom
riders" across the South on buses to force compliance with a Federal ban
on segregation in interstate travel. After repeated physical assaults in
Before 1963 the
Civil Rights movement achieved many local successes. In that year, it started
to pressure the federal government for sweeping change. This resulted in
several landmark pieces of civil rights legislation. In August the March On
Washington for Jobs and Freedom brought nearly 250,000 Americans to the
nation’s capital to demonstrate on behalf of a pending civil rights bill. It
was capped by King's stirring "I Have a Dream” speech envisioning an
integrated
The movement
then stepped up its campaign for voting rights. In 1964 the Twenty-fourth
Amendment to the Constitution was ratified, ending use of the poll tax. After a
Question: Be familiar with the contents of this
overview
Martin Luther
King, Jr., The Strategy of Nonviolent Direct Action
The lessons of
The goal of the
demonstrations in
1.
Nonviolent
demonstrators go into the streets to exercise their constitutional rights.
2.
Racists
resist by unleashing violence against them.
3.
Americans
of conscience in the name of decency demand federal intervention and
legislation.
4.
The
administration, under mass pressure, initiates measures of immediate intervention
and remedial legislation.
The working out
of this process has never been simple or tranquil. When nonviolent protests
were countered by local authorities with harassment, intimidation, and
brutality, the federal government has always first asked the Negro to desist
and leave the streets, rather than bring pressure to bear on those who commit
the criminal acts. We have always been compelled to reject vigorously such
federal requests and have rather relied on our allies, the millions of
Americans across the nation, to bring pressure on the federal government for
protective action in our behalf. Our position has always been that there is a
wrong and right side to the question of full freedom and equality for millions
of Negro Americans and that the federal government does not belong in the
middle on this issue.
During our
nonviolent direct-action campaigns we have always been advised, and again were
so advised in
Questions:
How does Martin Luther King define and promote nonviolent
direct action? Explain the concept
behind the strategy.
Fannie
Lou Hamer, Fighting for the Vote in
While national attention focused on King and other
prominent figures in the Civil Rights movement, the success of the struggle
often depended upon mobilizing the African American masses. Even though SCLC,
SNCC, and other civil rights organizations sent trained workers into southern
communities to coordinate campaigns against Jim Crow laws and disfranchisement,
those campaigns required the courage and determination of local people. In 1962
SNCC initiated a voter registration drive in
Mr. Chairman and
the Credentials Committee, my name is Mrs. Fannie Lou Hamer, and I live at 626
East Lafayette Street, Ruleville, Mississippi, Sunflower County, the home of
Senator James O. Eastland, and Senator [John] Stennis.
It was the 31st
of August in 1962 that eighteen of us traveled twenty -six miles to the county
courthouse in Indianola to try to register to try to become first-class
citizens. We was met in Indianola by
After we paid
the fine among us, we continued on to Ruleville, and Reverend Jeff Sunny
carried me four miles in the rural area where I had worked as a timekeeper and
sharecropper for eighteen years. I was met there by my children, who told me
the plantation owner was angry because I had gone down to try to register.
After they told me, my husband came, and said the plantation owner was raising
cain because I had tried to register, and before he quit talking the plantation
owner came, and said, "Fannie Lou, do you know-did Pap tell you what I
said?"
I said,
"Yes, sir."
He said, "I
mean that," he said. "If you don't go down and withdraw your registration,
you will have to leave," he said, "Then if you go down and
withdraw," he said. "You will-you might have to go because we are not
ready for that in
And I addressed
him and told him and said, "I didn't try to register for you. I tried to
register for myself." I had to leave that same night.
On the 10th of
September 1962, sixteen bullets was fired into the home of Mr. and Mrs. Robert
Tucker for me. That same night two girls were shot in
And in June, the
9th, 1963, I had attended a voter registration workshop, was returning back to
I got back on
the bus and one of the persons had used the washroom got back on the bus, too.
As soon as I was seated on the bus, I saw when they began to get the four people
in a highway patrolman's car. I stepped off the bus to see what was happening
and somebody screamed from the car that the four workers was in and said,
"Get that one there," and when I went to get in the car, when the man
told me I was under arrest, he kicked me.
I was carried to
the county jail, and put in the booking room. They left some of the people in
the booking room and began to place us in cells. I was placed in a cell with a
young woman.... After I was placed in the cell I began to hear sounds of licks
and screams. I could hear the sounds of licks and horrible screams, and I could
hear somebody say, "Can you say, yes sir, nigger? Can you say yes,
sir?"
And they would
say other horrible names. She would say, "Yes, I can say yes, sir."
"So say it."
She says,
"I don't know you well enough."
They beat her, I
don't know how long, and after a while she began to pray, and asked God to have
mercy on those people.
And it wasn't
too long before three white men came to my cell. One of these men was a State
Highway Patrolman and he asked me where I was from, and I told him Ruleville.
He said, "We are going to check this." And they left my cell and it
wasn't too long before they came back. He said, "You are from Ruleville
all right," and he used a curse word, and he said, "We are going to
make you wish you was dead."
I was carried
out of that cell into another cell where they had two Negro prisoners.
The State
Highway Patrolman ordered the first Negro to take the blackjack. The first
Negro prisoner ordered me, by orders from the State Highway Patrolman for me,
to lay down on a bunk bed on my face, and I laid on my face. The first Negro
began to beat, and I was beat by the first Negro until he was exhausted, and I
was holding my hands behind me at that time on my left side because I suffered
from polio when I was six years old. After the first Negro had beat until he
was exhausted, the State Highway Patrolman ordered the second Negro to take the
blackjack.
The second Negro
began to beat and I began to work my feet, and the State Highway Patrolman
ordered the first Negro who had beat to set on my feet to keep me from working
my feet. I began to scream and one white man got up and began to beat me in my
head and tell me to hush. One white man-my dress had worked up high, he walked
over and pulled my dress down-and he pulled my dress back, back up....
All of this on
account we want to register, to become first-class citizens, and if the Freedom
Democratic Party is not seated now, I question
Questions
Black Power, Black
Nationalism – Introduction
In the wake
of its greatest legislative triumph, the Civil Rights movement began to fragment.
On 11 August 1965, less than a week after the passage of the Voting Rights Act,
the black
The riots
illustrated the limits of the Civil Rights movement. By the 1960s, a majority
of African Americans lived in inner-city neighborhoods, most of them outside
the South. They faced no Jim Crow laws or disfranchisement devices, only the
economic ills and social alienation of places like Watts-widespread poverty,
massive unemployment, welfare, inadequate housing and schools, and racist
police. The boycotts, marches, sit-ins, and freedom rides had raised black
awareness and expectations but could do little to ameliorate the conditions of
ghetto life. Now many black activists, especially younger ones, searched for a
different strategy.
"Black
Power" became the new watchword. The term, coined by Stokely Carmichael in
1966, became a rallying cry for urban blacks increasingly alienated from the
Civil Rights movement. The idea derived from Black Nationalism-the belief that
people of African descent share a common experience, culture, world view, and
destiny. Most Black Power advocates were heavily influenced by Malcolm X, who
urged African Americans to band together and take control of their communities
"by any means necessary." Like Malcolm X, they generally eschewed the
goal of integration and the strategy of nonviolence. But Black Power meant
different things to different people. Most whites and some older blacks saw it
as synonymous with violence. For younger black activists, it usually referred
to self-reliance, race pride, and political and economic empowerment. The
rising importance of Black Power became evident in 1966 when both SNCC and CORE
embraced this more radical direction.
Black Power
advocates shared a common goal empowering black communities-but they differed
on how that would best be achieved. Revolutionary nationalist groups, such as
the Black Panther Party, called for armed struggle and espoused Marxist
thought. Seeing racism as an inevitable product of capitalism, they welcomed
alliances and coalitions with like-minded whites. Cultural nationalist groups,
such as the US Organization based in
Question: Be familiar with the contents of this
overview
Malcolm X, Black Nationalism and
Black Revolution
Most Black Power advocates
were inspired by the life and legacy of Malcolm X (1925-1965). Born Malcolm
Little, he suffered through a troubled childhood, only to become a teenage
hustler, pimp, and cocaine addict on the streets of Boston and Harlem. After a
bungled burglary, he was sent to prison, where he read voluminously and
converted to the separatist doctrines of Elijah Muhammad and the Nation of
Islam. Released in 1952, he was appointed the minister of a Harlem mosque.
Before long, his trenchant analysis of white racism, his confrontational
language, and his charismatic style made him into the chief evangelist for the
Black Muslims. But his growing popularity and independence brought estrangement
from Muhammad and the Nation. After a 1964 pilgrimage to Mecca, Malcolm X
became convinced of the possibility of white redemption, rejected his
unequivocal separatism, and considered politics as a possible vehicle for black
empowerment. But to the end, he continued to preach the value of black
nationalism and the likelihood of black revolution, as in the following 1964 speech.
After his assassination one year later, The
Autobiography of Malcolm X (1965) became a "nearly universal sacred
text" for the Black Power movement.
Friends and
enemies, tonight I hope that I can have a little fireside chat with as few
sparks as possible being tossed around. Especially because of the very
explosive condition that the world is in today. Sometimes, when a person's
house is on fire and someone comes in yelling fire, instead of the person who
is awakened by the yell being thankful, he makes the mistake of charging the
one who awakened him with having set the fire. I hope this little conversation
tonight about the black revolution won't cause many of you to accuse us of
igniting it when you find it at your doorstep....
I'm still a
Muslim but I'm also a nationalist, meaning that my political philosophy is
black nationalism, my economic philosophy is black nationalism, my social
philosophy is black nationalism. And when I say that this philosophy is black
nationalism, to me this means that the political philosophy of black
nationalism is that which is designed to encourage our people, the black
people, to gain complete control over the politics and politicians of our own
community.
Our economic
philosophy is that we should gain economic control over the economy of our own
community, the businesses and the other things which create employment so that
we can provide jobs for our own people instead of having to picket and boycott
and beg someone else for a job.
And, in
short, our social philosophy means that we feel that it is time to get together
among our own kind and eliminate the moral evils that are destroying the moral
fiber of our society, like drug addiction, drunkenness, adultery that leads to
an abundance of bastard children, welfare problems. We believe that we should
lift the level or the standard of our own society to a higher level wherein we
will be satisfied and then not inclined toward pushing ourselves into other
societies where we are not wanted....
By the
hundreds of thousands today we find our own people have become impatient,
turning away from your white nationalism, which you call democracy, toward the
militant uncompromising policy of black nationalism. I point out right here
that as soon as we announced we were going to start a black nationalist party
in this country we received mail from coast to coast, especially from young
people at the college level, the university level, who expressed complete
sympathy and support and a desire to take part in any kind of political action
based on black nationalism, designed to correct or eliminate immediately evils
that our people have suffered here for 400 years.
The black
nationalists too many of you may represent only a minority in the community.
And therefore you might have a tendency to classify them as something
insignificant. But just as the fuse is the smallest part or the smallest piece
in the powder keg it is yet that little fuse that ignites the entire powder
keg. The black nationalists to you may represent a small minority in the
so-called Negro community. But they just happen to be composed of the type of
ingredient necessary to fuse or ignite the entire black community. And this is
one thing that whites-whether you call yourselves liberals or conservatives or
racists or whatever else you might choose to be-one thing that you have to
realize is, where the black community is concerned, although there the large
majority you may come in contact with may impress you as being moderate and
patient and loving and long-suffering and all that kind of stuff, the minority
who you consider to be Muslims or nationalists happen to be made of the type
of ingredient that can easily spark the black community. This should be
understood. Because to me a powder keg is nothing without a fuse.
1964 will be
So today,
when the black man starts reaching out for what
Well,
Negroes didn't do these ten years ago. But what you should learn from this is
that they are waking up. It was stones yesterday, Molotov cocktails today; it
will be hand grenades tomorrow and whatever else is available the next day. The
seriousness of this situation must be faced up to. You should not feel that I
am inciting someone to violence. I'm only warning of a powder-keg
situation. You can take it or leave it. If you take the warning perhaps you
can still save yourself. But if you ignore it or ridicule it, well, death is
already at your doorstep. There are 22,000,000 African Americans who are ready
to fight for independence right here. When I say fight for independence right
here, I don't mean any non-violent fight, or turn-the-other-cheek fight. Those
days are gone. Those days are over.
If George
Washington didn't get independence for this country non-violently, and if
Patrick Henry didn't come up with a non-violent statement, and you taught me to
look upon them as patriots and heroes, then it's time for you to realize that I
have studied your books well....
This is a
real revolution.... Revolution is never based on begging somebody for an
integrated cup of coffee. Revolutions are never fought by turning the other
cheek.
Revolutions
are never based upon love your enemy, and pray for those who spitefully use
you. And revolutions are never waged singing, "We Shall Overcome."
Revolutions are based upon bloodshed. Revolutions are never compromising.
Revolutions are never based upon negotiations. Revolutions are never based upon
any kind of tokenism whatsoever. Revolutions are never even based upon that
which is begging a corrupt society or a corrupt system to accept us into it.
Revolutions overturn systems, and there is no system on this earth which has
proven itself more corrupt, more criminal than this .system, that in 1964 still
colonizes 22,000,000 African Americans.
Questions
Stokely Carmichael, Black Power
Defined
In 1966 Stokely Carmichael
(1942-1998), the new chairman of SNCC, gave the growing black nationalist
sentiment among younger activists both a name and a slogan when he called for
"Black Power." Born in the West Indies and raised in
We shall
have to struggle for the right to create our own terms through which to define
ourselves and our relationship to the society, and to have these terms
recognized. This is the first necessity of a free people....
Negroes are
defined by two forces, their blackness and their powerlessness. There have been
traditionally two communities in
This has not
been accidental. The history of every institution of this society indicates
that a major concern in the ordering and structuring of the society has been
the maintaining of the Negro community in its condition of dependence and
oppression. This has not been on the level of individual acts of discrimination
between individual whites against individual Negroes, but as total acts by the
White community against the Negro community. This fact cannot be too strongly
emphasized-that racist assumptions of white superiority have been so deeply
ingrained in the structure of the society that it infuses its entire
functioning, and is so much a part of the national subconscious that it is taken
for granted and is frequently not even recognized .... The ghetto itself is a
product of a combination of forces and special interests in the white
community, and the groups that have access to the resources and power to change
that situation benefit, politically and economically, from the existence of
that ghetto.
It is more
than a figure of speech to say that the Negro community in
It is white
power that makes the laws, and it is violent white power in the form of armed
white cops that enforces those laws with guns and nightsticks. The vast
majority of Negroes in this country live in these captive communities and must
endure these conditions of oppression because, and only because, they are
black and powerless....
SNCC
proposes that it is now time for the black freedom movement to stop pandering
to the fears and anxieties of the white middle class in the attempt to earn its
"goodwill," and to return to the ghetto to organize these
communities to control themselves. This organization must be attempted in
northern and southern urban areas as well as in the rural black belt counties
of the South.... We must organize black community power to end these abuses,
and to give the Negro community a chance to have its needs expressed.
Questions:
[1]
Roy E. Finkenbine, “Introducation The Civil Rights Movement. ”In Sources of the African
[2]
Saturday Review (3 April 1965)
[3] "Testimony of Fannie
Lou Hamer Before the Credentials Committee of the Democratic National
Convention," 22 August 1964, Joseph Rauh Papers, Library of Congress.