Evaluating & Assessing Students

written test

Recognizing that all students encounter external stressors at various points in life, it is important to acknowledge that any single snapshot of their performance may not accurately reflect their overall abilities. This approach ensures a more equitable evaluation process while addressing the varied needs and circumstances of students.

To promote fair and comprehensive evaluation, consider the following strategies:

  • Drop the Lowest Grade: Allow students the opportunity to exclude their lowest grade from their final evaluation, which can alleviate stress and provide a more balanced reflection of their performance.
  • Diversify Assessment Methods: Use a variety of assessment forms beyond traditional in-class exams, such as projects, presentations, or written reflections, to better capture students' understanding and skills.
  • Incorporate Formative Assessments: Use low-stakes, and ongoing assessments (such as quizzes, drafts, or practice assignments) to provide feedback and guide students' progress without the pressure of high-stakes grading.
  • Blind Grading: Consider grading written assignments anonymously to minimize the influence of unconscious biases.
  • Conduct Peer Assessments: Incorporate peer reviews, where students provide feedback on each other's work. This can enhance learning through collaboration and critical evaluation of others’ work.
  • Use Self-Assessments: Encourage students to reflect on their own work and learning progress by completing self-assessments, which can foster metacognition and personal growth.
  • Offer Flexible Deadlines: Provide some flexibility with deadlines to accommodate students dealing with external stressors or personal challenges, fostering a supportive learning environment.
  • Provide Ongoing Feedback: Offer continuous, constructive feedback throughout the course, rather than waiting for major assessments, to help students make timely improvements.
  • Offer Opportunities for Grade Improvement: Provide students with structured opportunities to revise assignments or recover lost points, allowing them to demonstrate growth and mastery of course material over time.
  • Adopt Equitable Grading Practices: Consider implementing alternative grading methods, such as ungrading, contract, or improvement-focused grading, that prioritize learning, self-reflection, and skill development over traditional point-based assessment.
  • Ensure Transparency and Accessibility in Grading: Maintain clear, up-to-date, and easily accessible records of student progress. Regularly communicate grading policies and expectations to ensure students understand how their work is evaluated and where they stand in the course.